Acute frustration ... and a plea for Hidden Creek



(Editor's Note: An important letter to the editor from Elspeth Nickle. What are your views? We'd love to hear from you.) 


October 17, 2014

The Honourable Jim Prentice
Premier of Alberta
307 Legislature Bldg.
10800 - 97 Avenue
Edmonton, AB  T5K 2B7

Dear Premier Prentice:

I am writing this letter to respectfully ask you to take action and close the trails to mechanized recreational traffic in the Hidden Creek area, one of the waterways in the upper Oldman watershed, in order to protect this valuable and vulnerable stream.

I have been motivated to write this letter because of:

1. The very marked deterioration of Hidden Creek and the area adjacent to it since my last visit only one and a half months ago.
2. Your announcement, as you introduced your new cabinet, that Alberta was under new management which has given me hope that some action might be taken. 
3. An entry which appeared on the AESRD blog on Oct. 4, 2014 which similarly raised my hope that the Forestry Service in this region might be amenable to action.

I am sending this letter by email directly to your office and copying it to a number of other individuals and organizations which I think will find it interesting; please see the cc. list at the bottom. I will follow up by sending it to you by registered mail.  I am hopeful for a timely reply and especially action but, if there is a holdup in your office and I do not hear from you, I will make the extra effort to call and speak with your staff in the hopes that this matter can be expedited.

The reason for my request of immediate action

Ten days my husband and I hiked on foot up Hidden Creek but our happy outing was marred upon our discovery that the conditions around Hidden Creek had badly and visibly deteriorated in the last month and a half.  The water quality in the stream was visibly murky, a marked contrast to the much better water quality on the same day in the upper Oldman, which we forded on foot in order to get into the Hidden Creek area.

The extensive motorized recreational traffic on the trail, which runs in very close proximity to the stream, and recent rains have clearly contributed to this deterioration.  The pictures I have enclosed are by no means isolated shots; the whole of the length of the trail we walked showed similar deterioration. 

Conditions on the trail

Although we were there on a Wednesday (October 1, 2014), when we expected traffic to be nil to low, at least half a dozen ATVs past us.  (We were the only ones on foot).  This is an old trail, which is leftover from I think previous logging or seismic explorations, but it has not reverted to its natural state because, as you can see from the pictures, it is very extensively used.  With the approaching high point of the hunting season, activity can only be expected to increase.

I am sure you are aware that water quality is a prime indicator of the overall health and viability of the watershed; poor water quality can indicate excessive runoff, the inability of the watershed to hold back and store water, or increased difficulty for native fish populations to spawn successfully.   Hidden Creek is one of the few remaining areas in the Crowsnest where native bull trout are still found in any appreciable numbers.  It is worrisome to think what the future holds if current conditions prevail.


​Note the fresh tire marks to the left.  Hidden Creek is less than 5 metres to the left of those tracks!

The AESRD blog entry, Oct 4, 2014.

After this disheartening experience, I read with considerable hope the AERSRD blog entry of Oct. 4, 2014 which exhorted the public to learn "how to minimize the impacts of your activities on Alberta's plant and animal habitats" and provided links to Alberta's Species at Risk Guide. 

On page 16, I was pleased to find out that the bull trout is a species at risk, that it is Alberta's provincial fish, and that under Threats, AESRD recognized that "Populations remain low because of habitat loss and degradation (such as sediments in streams) from industrial activity, especially roads" 

Then, in a section entitled How Can You Help?, it suggests among other things:
1) Keep off-highway vehicles out of creeks and streams  and use bridges for stream crossings.
2)Report hanging culverts and off-highway vehicles driving in streams to our nearest [A]ESRD office. 

It seems that AESRD has a very good handle on the direction needed to be taken.  In this case, with the extremely close proximity of the trail to the creek in the Hidden Creek watershed, one could conclude that the road itself is so close, it might as well be in Hidden Creek!  Also, any of the ATV;s we saw had most certainly forded the Oldman in the same place we had to get to the area, and that is most certainly not in keeping with the advice in the Species at Risk Guide.


​More conditions on the trail

Further, in my dealings with conservation minded groups, which incidentally is also encouraged in the "How Can You Help?" section, I can attest that there is an acute frustration about reporting off-highway vehicle activity to the nearest AESRD office. It doesn't actually result in any substantive action being taken, or hasn't in the past.  By writing this letter to you, and copying it to the nearest AESRD office, I am hoping for a different outcome.

I am very much hoping that when you said that Alberta was under new management, you meant it. I look forward to your response at your earliest convenience.

Yours very truly,
Elspeth J. Nickle

cc:
Honourable Kyle Fawcett, Miinster of Environment, AERSD
Craig Johnson, Fisheries, Blairmore, AERSD
Matthew Coombs, Fisheries, Blairmore, AERSD
Terry Clayton, Fisheries, Lethbridge, AERSD
Emeric Janssens, Fisheries, Lethbridge, AERSD
Paul Christensen, Fisheries, Calgary, AERSD
Sara Burnstead, Fisheries, Calgary, AERSD
Jennifer Earl, Fisheries, Cochrane, AERSD
Bev Yee,  Assistant Deputy Minister, Integrated Resource Management Planning Division, Environment and Sustainable Resource Development, AERSD
Tim Juhl, Timber, Blairmore, AERSD
Rupert Hewison,Timber, Blairmore, AERSD
Craig Harriott, Timber, Blairmore, AERSD
Mike Taje, Land Use, Blairmore, AERSD
Leo Dube, Wildlife Management, Lethbridge, AERSD
Greg Hale, Wildlife Management, Pincher Creek, AERSD

Bridget Pastoor, MLA, Lethbridge East
Greg Weadick, MLA, Lethbridge West
Danielle Smith, Wildrose Party Leader
Mr. Joe Anglin, Wildrose Environment Critic
Mr. Pat Stier, MLA, Livingstone-Macleod
Raj Sherman, Alberta Liberal Party Leader
Laurie Blakeman, Alberta Liberal Party Environment Critic
Brian Mason, Alberta New Democratic Party Leader

Shannon Frank, Oldman Watershed Council, Executive Director, Lethbridge.
Katie Morrison, Conservation Director, Canadian Parks and Wilderness Society - Southern Alberta
Karsten Heuer, President, Yellowstone-to-Yukon Initiative
Leanne Elias, Field Notes Collective
Lorne Fitch, Wildlife Biologist
Justina C. Ray, Wildlife Conservation Society Canada, Executive Director and Senior Scientist




It's all about sustaining bull trout

By Richard Burke
I was a touch ambivalent about the walk I was about to take down the Upper Wigwam River in Southeastern B.C. It is a beautiful river, worth spending time on, and this trip had a particularly useful purpose – counting bull trout redds – not that simply being there and soaking it up isn’t useful.

The older I get, though, the harder it is on the feet and knees to walk and wade on river rocks. So, I reminded myself, this was about the bull trout, not me.
The trip overall was noteworthy, part of a three-day conference on bull tryout organized by Will Warnock and others for the Salvenlinus confluentus Curiosity Society. The conference, attended by mainly scientists from six states and five provinces to hear or present new information on bull trout, was held at Blue Lake Centre, a rustic cluster of cabins and a lodge mainly for educational meetings. It was a half hour west of Canal Flats, B.C. at the south end of Columbia Lake up dusty logging roads well into the Purcells.

The Upper Wigwam is more than 200 km southeast of that, accessible by more dusty logging roads within hailing distance of the Montana border. The Wigwam, in fact, has its source in Montana.
Four teams, a total of 12 participants, counted redds – spawning areas in the gravel river bed – over 20 km. My team was led by Will. The other team member was Kathryn Kuchapski. Both have much younger feet and knees. It was either by design or by fortunate chance I was with them. Both are graduates of the University of Lethbridge – Will's years there culminated in a PhD in Biosystems and Biodiversity in 2012. I had sat in the university classroom when Will defended his Masters thesis a couple of years before that. His affinity for bull trout was reflected in his thesis.

During his time in Lethbridge, he had presented information to the Oldman River Chapter Trout Unlimited about bull trout migrating between the Castle River and Hidden Creek in the Upper Oldman River. Kathryn received her MSc in Biological Sciences in 2013. Both are shining examples of education at work for good.


But, I digress, sort of. Again, this effort was about bull trout. In our 5 km section, we counted 308 redds, which seemed significant.  Overall in the four sections, team members counted more than 500 redds. A survey is conducted annually in the entire Wigwam, the count ranging from 1,500 to about 2,000. The river is B.C.’s single largest spawning run of adult bull trout (3,000–5,000 adults annually). They spawn in autumn then swim downstream, as far as Lake Kookanusa about 50 km to the west (with much more ease than an older man negotiating river rocks, I thought.)

Southeastern B.C. was chosen for the conference, partly because it is “bull trout heaven,” said Will. By contrast, in Alberta across the border from the Wigwam and other thriving  B.C. streams, it is a threatened species. That means it’s “likely to become endangered if nothing is done to reverse factors leading to extirpation or extinction.” In B.C., it is a species of special concern – less than threatened but still monitored carefully to make sure it doesn't decline.
Jeff Burrows of the B.C. Ministry of Forest Lands and Natural Resource Operations, Fish and Wildlife Branch, told the conference counts by various methods put bull trout numbers at about 14,000 in the East Kootenay alone. In all of Alberta, provincial estimates placed the Alberta bull trout population at approximately 20,000 adults in a 2014 update.

"Since the provincial regulation change to a zero harvest regulation for bull trout in 1995, a number of bull trout populations have recovered to some extent, while others have stabilized at low population levels. In a number of cases, bull trout may have decreased or even disappeared from certain streams,” according to the bull trout management plan.

When I asked Jeff about a perceived superior approach to fisheries in B.C. compared with Alberta, he smiled,  saying only, “We have to make our cases.”
He also supervised the redd-counting effort on the Wigwam, leading us to the muster point 52 km up from Hwy. 3 at an elevation of 1,300 metres. We passed through locked gates “there to keep motorized vehicles out,” Jeff said. When asked about enforcement, he said if a vehicle is reported in the area, it is thoroughly investigated. Noticeably absent in the restricted area were ATVs and RVs.

I was at the conference as a member of the TU Oldman River Chapter, which acts as steward on about 4 km of Crowsnest River frontage it leases in the Crowsnest Pass. My participation there was to bring information back to the chapter on bull trout habitat and recovery efforts elsewhere.
Here are some other takeaways from the conference and the Alberta Bull Trout Conservation Management Plan 2012-17 about bull trout that may help our chapter (and other groups) determine how it may help in bringing back bull trout numbers:

• The species needs cool water (13 C)  to thrive. Those temperatures are generally found in lakes and streams in higher elevations, like the Oldman River headwaters which has significant concerns from over use by industry and recreational users that affects bull trout spawning areas. According to the Alberta Bull Trout Conservation Management Plan, “Generally, bull trout populations in the southern watersheds – Oldman, Bow and Red Deer rivers – have experienced the greatest declines. . . . The fact that many bull trout populations have not recovered, or are still considered vulnerable, has largely been a consequence of the increasing cumulative impacts of industrial and recreational activities within the species historic range as well as competition from introduced fish species” such as brook trout.


• Bull Trout have been abused in Alberta for at least a century. (The one at right we found dead on the Wigwam rocks.) You can find frequent references to the species being considered a trash fish and caught then thrown into the bushes. Angling regulations have been changed recently to catch and release on all trout in the Oldman drainage. “Where bull trout recovery has occurred (in other jurisdictions), it has been largely due to angling regulation changes and related management activities including: (1) zero harvest limit, (2) bait bans, (3) seasonal and permanent angling closures in key spawning, staging and over wintering areas, (4) public awareness and education efforts to reduce fish mis-identification and unintentional harvest, and (5) enforcement efforts to reduce illegal harvest," according to the recovery plan.

Alberta has so far been slow to respond to pleas for increased enforcement. And, according to the BT management plan, “While a few populations are abundant and may be increasing, generally, angling restrictions alone have not been adequate to recover bull trout populations.”

• Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development, the department which has responsibility for fish, is studying bull trout sustainability. Jessica Reilly told conference participants “the sustainability of bull trout in Alberta was recently evaluated (in 89 areas of the province) to determine whether the stock is healthy, fish abundance and threat mitigation,” starting with the question: What is the state of Alberta’s fishery? Early findings include: road density above 1.4 km per square km is “probably bad for bull trout” and the areas which showed the highest adult bull trout density in the province were all in national parks.

By the way, road density is a priority for action in the Oldman Watershed Council Headwaters Action Plan.

• The bull trout was declared Alberta’s official fish in 1995 as a way of highlighting its shaky status. According to the Alberta Culture and Tourism website:  “The bull trout is one of eight species of trout found in the province's glacial waters. To ensure Alberta's population of bull trout never becomes endangered, there is a catch and release policy governing all bull trout fishing in the province.”

There is no mention in the message of factors other than fishing that have contributed to the fish’s decline, such as “resource development (that) creates high-risk environments for bull trout due to the cumulative effects of degraded habitat conditions combined with increased angler access,” according to the bull trout recovery plan.

• Bull trout “threatened” designation is based on federal legislation which requires the province to develop a recovery plan, but it takes an inordinate amount of time to develop plans and legislation does not force recovery activities, says Rick Taylor of the University of British Columbia, who sits on the committee which determines wildlife status under the Canada Species At Risk Act.

He also says, “There is no question recent weakened federal legislation will weaken protection of bull trout.”

• The Waterton River drainage has been studied recently by Alberta Conservation Association fisheries biologists, who categorized the system as high risk, low recovery potential. The ACA's Jason Blackburn pointed to problems that started in the early 20th century with developments such as Oil City in Waterton Lakes National Park. Other obstacles to bull trout recovery focus on hybridization (with brook trout) and high stream temperature variations from the top of the system in streams such as Spionkop, which with Yarrow and Blakiston Creeks had the highest numbers of adult bull trout in the survey. In lower sections, temperature is likely too high for bull trout.

Blackburn’s assessment of the likelihood for bull trout recovery is “there’s still hope, if someone cares enough.”

• Alberta also has a Westslope Cutthroat Recovery Plan because that species is also threatened. Alberta Cows and Fish Riparian Habitat Management Society has been front and centre in trying to move from planning to action on recovery of the two fish species. A work day to repair some Allison Creek riparian habitat is scheduled for Oct. 24. Oldman River Chapter has been invited to participate. As well, the chapter has offered to adopt Hidden Creek, a prime bull trout spawning area. What that might entail has yet to be determined.

Can You Help Rescue Our Fish? - IT BEGINS NOW!

Trout Unlimited Canada’s Alberta Fish Rescue

                       Trout Unlimited Canada has begun our annual
                  Fish Rescue from irrigation canals in southern Alberta!

Volunteers transport fish to be measured on shore

Throughout the summer, fish enter Alberta’s irrigation canals as water is diverted from rivers and reservoirs for irrigation and municipal use.  Most of the canals do not have any fish exclusion devices to prevent this from happening.  Once fish enter the canals, they are unable to return to their original systems.

In late fall, the canals are drained and can no longer support aquatic life.  With the help of hundreds of volunteers, Trout Unlimited Canada (with support from Alberta Environment and Sustainable Resource Development), captures thousands of fish and relocates them to functional waterbodies where they can carry out their life cycles.

Since the commencement of Trout Unlimited Canada’s fish salvages in 1996, over 800,000 fish have been rescued. The 2013 Fish Rescue resulted in the capture of 12,036 sportfish and 23,535 non-sportfish — a total of 35,571 fish were recovered from five irrigation canals in southern Alberta. 

Eight sport species and eleven non-sport species were captured at Women's Coulee Diversion (WCD), Western Headworks Canal (WHC), Carseland Bow River Headworks Canal (CBRHC), Waterton-Belly Diversion (WBD) and Lethbridge Northern Headworks Canal (LNHC). This year we will also include the Mountain View Leavitt Aetna Headworks Canal (MVLAHC).


              
 
 In addition to the actual fish salvage, valuable data is collected on the species, size composition, and abundance of entrained fish. The Fish Rescue is also an excellent educational opportunity for adults and children.  Volunteers are given the opportunity to learn about fish identification, handling, life history, and conservation.

Adult volunteers equipped with chest waders may also have the chance to assist the electrofishing crew by dip-netting or transporting fish out of the canal.

If you are interested in participating, we are still looking for volunteers to help us with the Lethbridge Northern Headworks Canal Rescue in the Granum/Fort Macleod area taking place October 15, 16, and 17. 

Please contact Elliot Lindsay ELindsay@tucanada.org  or Lesley Peterson LPeterson@tucanada.org

For a full description of the Trout Unlimited Fish Rescue and detailed results, please visit our website at http://www.tucanada.org/index.asp?p=2027

__________________________________________________________________________________________
Lesley Peterson (P.Biol.)  Provincial Biologist   Trout Unlimited Canada
#160, 6712 Fisher St. SE, Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2H 2A7
        
O/ 1-800-909-6040   D/ 403-209-5185   C/ 403-875-3264   F/ 403-221-8368  


To Conserve, Protect and Restore Canada’s Freshwater Ecosystems
and Their Coldwater Resources for Current and Future Generations.


Kelsey's Column - A Young Voice for the Oldman

Hi everyone it's Kelsey here!

Last weekend my dad and I participated in the annual Shoreline Cleanup. It was so much fun and I was able to handout tons of my Storm Drain Survival Kits (http://www.lethbridge.ca/living-here/water-wastewater/Pages/Stormdrain-Survival-Kit.aspx).  The Shoreline Cleanup was held at the Helen Schuler Nature center and we cleaned the Oldman River shoreline from there. We found a fair amount of garbage including a bike, pillow case, and socks. For more information on the Shoreline Cleanup you can visit the website at: http://www.lethbridge.ca/NewsCentre/Pages/Shoreline-Cleanup-2014.aspx.



COMING SOON.......
Lethbridge's  annual Green Life Expo is coming up on Saturday, October 18th from 10:00 am-5:00 pm at Exhibition Park. Inside there will be a ceremony called The Green Seed and I will be there handing out my Storm Drain Survival Kit's.


WHAT'S THE GREEN SEED?
The green seed is a ceremony where you can win prizes and receive awards for helping the environment. You can nominate your friends, family, or strangers to the Green Seed for helping our watershed or environment. There will also be food, information booths, and presentations. 

 

Tribute to Bill Brown - A Strong Watershed Voice Remembered

(Editor's note: Cheryl Bradley has sent in a moving tribute to Bill Brown, who was one of the pioneers of the OWC and the pre-OWC entities. A donation to the OWC's film project has been in his name. Thank you, Cheryl - and thank you Bill - for all you do to make our watershed a good place to live, work and play.)

Tribute to Bill Brown (1926-2014)
By Cheryl Bradley

Photo kindly provided by Bill's daughter, Fiona

Bill Brown, an active member of SAGE for over a quarter of a century, passed away on September 7, 2014 at the age of 87 years.  He will be greatly missed. 

Bill helped to direct the work of SAGE as Board member for twelve years (1994-2006) including holding the position of Chair (1994-1997) and Secretary (2004-2006).  His volunteer efforts also benefited other local environmental organizations, including the Lethbridge Naturalists Society, Lethbridge Fish & Game Association, Castle Crown Wilderness Coalition and Southern Alberta Community of Environmental Educators. 

Even in the last few years as his health was failing, Bill continued to follow environmental issues in our community, to advocate for environmental protection, and to mentor a new generation of environmental activists and nature appreciators.

Nature was an interest and passion for Bill beginning with his childhood as son of a gamekeeper on an estate in Scotland. He studied botany and horticulture at both the Royal Botanic Garden in Edinburgh and the Birmingham Botanic Garden, interrupted by a stint in the navy near the end of the Second World War.  In 1957, Bill immigrated to Canada to work for City of Edmonton Parks and in 1961 moved to Lethbridge to become the Superintendent of Parks and Recreation.  He remained in that position until 1987.

Bill’s foresight established the framework for the amazing network of parks and green spaces our community enjoys today and advanced environmental literacy in Lethbridge.  During his 26 years working with the City of Lethbridge, Bill oversaw development of the Helen Schuler Coulee Centre and designation of several urban river valley parks. He was instrumental in drafting the City’s River Valley Redevelopment Plan, which set a tone towards protecting the river valley environment from major developments. 

Following his retirement from civil service, Bill’s strong and impassioned voice for nature was heard often in our community. Putting his Toastmaster skills to good use, he served as Master of Ceremonies for several environmental events in Lethbridge and gave numerous presentations on environmental topics.  

Bill spoke at public hearings regarding Lethbridge parkland, environmental impacts of the Oldman River Dam, forest management planning in Cypress Hills Provincial Park, and expansion of ski hills in national parks.  He developed briefs for SAGE on matters such as provincial water policy, national parks policy, integrating environment and economy in municipal planning, promoting development of wind power, and reducing use of pesticides. 

Bill worked on committees with a mandate to re-design the entrance to the Liz Hall Wetlands, plan a bridge bicycle trail across the Oldman River, mitigate adverse impacts of the Oldman River Dam, and expand a network of protected areas in the prairies of southern Alberta.  For four years he represented SAGE on the Board of Alberta Ecotrust, a role that allowed him input on decisions about funding environmental projects throughout the province.

Bill’s accomplishments did not go unnoticed. In 1997 he received the Lethbridge Urban Wildlife Steward Award, recognizing his work towards protecting wildlife and its habitat in the City of Lethbridge.  In 2008, friends and colleagues nominated him for an Emerald Award for his lifetime commitment as a friend and advocate of the environment.

My conversations with Bill in the later years of his life revealed an abiding love and enthusiasm for nature, pride in his accomplishments and that of his protégés, and profound disappointment that leadership is lacking at all levels of government with regard to environmental stewardship. 

Bill had a special twinkle in his eye remembering his work with the “ABC Team”. Together with Tom Atkinson and Sylvia Campbell he drew on his knowledge of public policy and mobilized the community to successfully challenge development of a motel and expansion of a golf course in urban parkland. The city council of the day was surprised by the strong reminder of the community’s commitment to parks and the need to consult on matters affecting public parkland.


With Bill’s passing SAGE loses a staunch supporter and nature loses a strong advocate.  SAGE, and our community, have benefited greatly from Bill’s work and his love of our watershed.